User Blog: Comparing Manga and Britcomics festivals: social community and exhibition
Written By: Andy Luke
Date: 5 Jan 2010

Manga’s acceptance is largely generation-ally linked to generation, according to Paul Gravett in 60 Years of Manga, steadily rising between 1963 and 2003. Although the form still faces acceptance issues in some areas, particularly after the media panic surrounding Tsutomu Miyazaki in 1989. Although nowadays, it's been adopted by the Government as a medium (The Ministry of Finance printed their Environmental White Paper in manga form in 1994), and worthy of economic sponsorship to the tune of 15 trillion yen. Allen and Ingulsrud (2003) and Kinsella (2005)  recognise acceptance of manga is not universal, and suggest that this is part of what allows them to be “a powerful source of information.” Likewise in Britain, there is a generational link, though one were comics have died and thrived tied into marketer’s whims, despite an enthusiastic ‘small press’, often similar to fanzines and distributed largely by mail order, comics shows, and nowadays Internet sales. Or ‘dojinshi.’ Wilson and Toku write,

“The term dojinshi was originally applied to manga-like fanzines, the hobby magazines and comic books produced by amateurs... The term dojinshi has come to refer to both a club or circle of high school or college students who create their own comic books, and to the comic books themselves.”

 

Festivals

Rating:
[Complain about this item]



Leave a Comment

View Comments (2)

Hi Shane. Certainly it's a question you've asked yourself in preparing the BICS show, ie. as to what sort of event you'd like to create from it. If it helps, strip back were I set forward a case, to consider these comparisons as probes: to pose questions and attempt to find answers. Perhaps it is not necessarry or justified, in the same vein that coagulating comics events together thtough definition of form and concern may or may not be. A sociologist, or even a Leisure studies or Cultural and Arts Management student might say they are, by virtue of shared attributes. I think articles like this and my Sheridan Cottage series only really work when they are discussed and questioned with the proper language.

Thought Bubble should have been worth a mention with it's Manga championing: this could lead to representations of British cultural representation in Japan. I daresay Comica UK would also be worth an expanded mention given it's longevity. I was constrained by time and wanted to feature British festivals I had first hand experience of. Either of those may have made a better inclusion than LUC, which at the time of writing was ongoing: so shouldn't have made it to my final draft.
Posted by Andy Luke on 20 January 2010 19:13
Andy... I have to ask my old friend:

Is there a reason in comparing events with totally different aims and onbjectives?

All the events achieve their own aims to a certain extent so is comparison neccessary or even justified?

I think that Thought Bubble is also worth mentioning as it champions Manga in a big way, introducing it to a more mainstream comics readership.

all the best

Shane
Posted by Shane Chebsey on 13 January 2010 14:14

Advertise with us
Advertise with us